|
Neubauer Artists LLC Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Liquidating entire business would put more than 9,000 jobs at risk
A liquidation plan at Canada’s oldest company could begin at all of its locations as soon as Tuesday and last for up to 12 weeks, but Hudson’s Bay is still holding out hope that it will find a lifeline.
Lawyers for the beleaguered retailer said in an Ontario court Monday morning that if approved by the judge, the liquidation would span 80 stores as well as three Saks Fifth Avenue stores and 13 Saks Off 5th locations in Canada that it owns through a licensing agreement.
The process Hudson’s Bay is proposing would allow the retailer to remove some stores from the liquidation, should it find sufficient financing during the 10 to 12 weeks when lawyer Ashley Taylor expects the company to offload its inventory.
“A quick start will maximize the value of the business … and preserve whatever chance there is of a restructuring,” Taylor told Ontario Superior Court Judge Peter Osborne in a hearing at a Toronto courtroom Monday.
The hearing attracted so many lawyers, media and other observers that an overflow room had to be opened to facilitate spectators there to learn what will come of the retailer dating back to 1670, when the country was involved with the fur trade.
The hearing was meant to advance a creditor protection case Hudson’s Bay launched March 7, when it admitted it was struggling with financial difficulties amid subdued consumer spending, Canada-U.S. trade tensions and post-pandemic drops in downtown store traffic.
It said the situation has become so bad that it deferred some payments to landlords, service providers and vendors and was days away from not being able to meet payroll obligations.
As it struggled, a landlord “unlawfully locked” Hudson’s Bay out of a store located in Sydney, N.S., and a team of bailiffs attempted to seize merchandise from a location it runs in Toronto, Ont., mall Sherway Gardens, said Jennifer Bewley, the chief financial officer for Hudson’s Bay’s parent company, in a court filing.
Financing falls apart
When the company filed for creditor protection, Hudson’s Bay lawyer Taylor said the retailer’s plan was to restructure by liquidating half its stores and monetizing some of the leases it tends to hold in prime, high-traffic spaces.
That plan was to be carried out under debtor-in-possession financing, which lenders make available to troubled companies in order to help them restructure.
In the run-up to the March 7 court hearing, Taylor said the company had two lenders interested in supplying that funding. But three hours before, the financing from its chosen suitor “fell apart” and the retailer “scrambled” to get an alternative together.
It’s since reached out to at least 19 potential lenders and major landlords who could offer rent concessions.
“To date, the company’s efforts have failed,” Taylor said in court Monday as he described why the company needed to pursue liquidation.
Ontario takes the biggest hit
The liquidation Hudson’s Bay is seeking will span the company’s entire footprint, with Ontario taking the bulk of the hit because it’s where the company has 32 locations and more than half of its employees work. B.C. hosts 16 locations; Alberta and Quebec each have 13; and Manitoba, Nova Scotia and Saskatchewan have two per province.
Saks Fifth Avenue’s Canadian sites are split between Ontario and Alberta and Saks Off 5th has stores in Ontario, B.C., Alberta, Quebec and Manitoba.
Liquidating its entire business would put more than 9,000 jobs at risk.
Elizabeth Pillon, another lawyer who appeared on Hudson’s Bay’s behalf, said the company has about $315 million in inventory on its balance sheet right now and the proposed liquidation will extend to its e-commerce business, which will continue until the company’s Scarborough, Ont., distribution centre empties.
The company plans to stop accepting gift cards after April 6 and has already paused its loyalty program, with more than 8.2 million Canadian customers holding about $58.5 million in unused points.
Hudson’s Bay is also seeking permission to launch a process to find a buyer for some or all of its properties or the business.
The process would allow potential buyers to make a bid for some of the company’s leases or just intellectual property, like Hudson’s Bay’s branding or rights to its famed stripe trademarks.
The company will also keep seeking financing. But some experts say finding a backer will be no easy feat for a business that has struggled with even “simple” matters like keeping escalators working.
“It is a major challenge and no doubt with some large strings attached,” said Lanita Layton, a luxury and retail consultant and a former Holt Renfrew vice-president, in an email.
“Depending on who, if anyone does bring the financing, I don’t foresee HBC continuing in the same format.”
She says Hudson’s Bay’s most logical path forward will be shrinking the company to a “manageable size” by operating a smaller number of stores more “conducive to today’s customer desires,” which include a unique product mix, experiential opportunities, exciting visuals and great customer service.
“This marks the end of a nearly 400-year-old institution which is going to have significant impacts in reshaping the Canadian retail landscape, with major consequences for employees, customers, as well as broader retailers operating in Canada,” said Jenna Jacobson, director of the Retail Leadership Institute at Toronto Metropolitan University.
This could be a real challenge for malls as large department stores act as the anchors in a lot of malls and also act as the driver to bring in consumers, she said.
“Filling that space is very challenging, because what retailer is able to take over that amount of space.”
Origins of Hudson’s Bay
Hudson’s Bay Company, in its original form, was founded by fur traders and owned a vast tract of northern Canada around Hudson Bay where it operated a far-flung chain of trading posts.
Dating back to 1670, it has been deeply entrenched in Canadian history, but has been led by Americans for several decades now.
The architect behind most of the Bay’s modern history is Richard Baker, an American real estate titan whose National Realty and Development Corp. Equity Partners bought the company in 2008 from the widow of late South Carolina businessman Jerry Zucker for $1.1 billion.
Baker took it public in 2012, only to reverse course through a takeover bid that had to be sweetened twice before shareholders accepted it in early 2020, ahead of the COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns.
Source: CBC
About The Author
